This is what I bought with the only difference being the size 4" x 6". Is this what you are using?
The ones I am using appear to be from the same company, but in addition to the size I am using being 4 X 6 they are card sleeves and the product you showed says it is designed for photos and sheets. I don't know if that somehow could make a difference or not, but the 4 X 6 ones I have really work great.
I work at a card shop and was looking for stuff for my old original cotg cards and yeah they are just a bit too wide for your standard 4 x 6 top loaders. However Ultra pro does make a 4 x 6 side loader that worked perfectly (perfectly fits width but you will have a little under an inch extra space up top) They seemed snug enough also to me to not worry about the casual falling out, though if you intentionally turn them open side down they will fall out. Don't have the link to ultra pro's webpage right now but a quick search for ultrapro 4x6 toploader side load turns up alot of various options.
The Ultra Pro Top loaders 4x6 work perfectly. I buy all mine from the2buds.com and never had a problem with any card fitting.
same here, no problems at all with those ones
My guess is the cards arent consistent between types and game years. 2087 through 2091 cotg cards most def were around 1/4" too wide for 4x6 top loads but fine for side loads. Did not try any other years and just orderd all the 4x6 side loads I needed from work since it's not a big deal to me if they load from the side or top.